In the world of pedestrian traffic management, selecting the right turnstile solution can mean the difference between seamless security and operational bottlenecks. As a leading manufacturer with over a decade of experience, DOOR understands that this decision impacts everything from security protocols to architectural aesthetics, operational efficiency to long-term maintenance costs.
This comprehensive guide will help facility managers, security directors, architects, and system integrators make informed decisions between three popular turnstile types: Sliding Turnstiles, Swing Gates, and Speed Gates. We'll explore their unique characteristics, optimal applications, and key considerations for your specific environment.
Sliding turnstiles feature horizontally moving panels that glide smoothly to create a passageway. Their defining characteristics include:
Movement: Horizontal sliding motion
Space Requirement: Minimal footprint (typically 300-400mm depth)
Operation Speed: Moderate to fast (1-2 seconds per cycle)
Noise Level: Exceptionally quiet (40-50 dB)
Security Level: Medium to High
Modern office building lobbies where aesthetics and quiet operation are priorities
Residential complexes requiring 24/7 access with minimal disturbance
Healthcare facilities where noise reduction is critical
Mixed-use developments with space constraints
Corporate headquarters seeking premium, sophisticated access solutions
Our sliding turnstiles, like the DR.TD.6992 series, incorporate advanced servo drive systems and intelligent anti-tailgating algorithms. The modular design allows for easy maintenance and future upgrades, while the slim profile (as narrow as 280mm in some models) maximizes usable space without compromising security.
Swing gates operate on a hinged mechanism, similar to traditional doors but with controlled access functionality:
Movement: Arc-based swinging motion
Space Requirement: Moderate to significant (requires clearance arc)
Operation Speed: Slower (2-3 seconds per cycle)
Noise Level: Moderate (50-60 dB)
Security Level: Medium
Industrial facilities with ample space
Parking garage entrances/exits
Warehouse and logistics centers
Budget-conscious projects where cost is primary
Moderate traffic areas without space constraints
While swing gates often present a lower initial investment, consider their spatial requirements—they typically need 30-40% more clearance area than sliding alternatives. Additionally, their mechanical pivot points may require more frequent maintenance in high-traffic environments.
Also known as optical turnstiles or glass gates, speed gates use retractable barriers and sophisticated sensors:
Movement: Vertical barrier retraction
Space Requirement: Minimal to moderate
Operation Speed: Very fast (0.5-1 second per cycle)
Noise Level: Low to moderate
Security Level: Medium to High (depending on barrier design)
Transportation hubs (airports, metro stations) with extreme traffic volumes
Stadiums and entertainment venues requiring rapid crowd management
Corporate campuses with thousands of daily entries
Financial institutions balancing security with customer throughput
Educational institutions between class periods
Speed gates excel in environments where maximizing person-per-minute (PPM) throughput is critical. Our DR.TD.6627 series can handle up to 60 persons per minute under optimal conditions, with customizable barrier options from waist-high to full-height security levels.
Feature | Sliding Turnstile | Swing Gate | Speed Gate |
Installation Depth | 280-400mm | 500-800mm | 300-600mm |
Clearance Arc | None required | 90-120° arc | Minimal |
Best For Tight Spaces | Excellent | Poor | Good |
Metric | Sliding Turnstile | Swing Gate | Speed Gate |
Cycles/Hour | 1,500-2,000 | 800-1,200 | 3,000-4,000 |
Noise Level | 40-50 dB | 50-60 dB | 45-55 dB |
Power Consumption | 100-150W | 80-120W | 120-180W |
ADA Compliance | Customizable | Standard | Available |
Security Aspect | Sliding Turnstile | Swing Gate | Speed Gate |
Anti-Tailgating | Advanced | Basic | Advanced |
Forced Entry Resistance | High | Medium | Medium-High |
Integration Complexity | Low-Medium | Low | Medium-High |
Visual Deterrence | High | Medium | High |
Cost Factor | Sliding Turnstile | Swing Gate | Speed Gate |
Initial Investment | $$-$$$ | $-$$ | $$$-$$$$ |
Maintenance Cost/Year | $ | $$ | $$-$$$ |
Energy Cost/Year | $ | $ | $$ |
Total Cost of Ownership | $$ | $$-$$$ | $$$ |
Answer these critical questions:
What is your peak hourly traffic?
< 500 persons/hour: All options suitable
500-1,500 persons/hour: Consider sliding or speed gates
1,500 persons/hour: Speed gates recommended
What are your spatial constraints?
Tight corridors/lobbies: Sliding turnstiles
Ample space: Swing gates
Modern open layouts: Speed gates
What is your security level requirement?
Basic access control: Swing gates
Medium security with aesthetics: Sliding turnstiles
High throughput with security: Speed gates
Indoor vs. Outdoor: Sliding and speed gates typically excel indoors; swing gates are often more weather-resistant for outdoor use
Architectural style: Modern/minimalist designs pair best with sliding or speed gates
Noise sensitivity: Healthcare and libraries favor sliding turnstiles
Existing systems: Ensure compatibility with your access control software
Future expansion: Modular designs (like DOOR's sliding turnstiles) offer easier upgrades
Multi-system integration: Consider gates that interface with visitor management, CCTV, and building automation
Don't just consider purchase price. Factor in:
Installation complexity and cost
Expected maintenance frequency and cost
Energy consumption
Expected lifespan (DOOR sliding turnstiles offer 5-8 years minimum)
Warranty coverage and support availability
Primary Choice: Sliding Turnstiles
Why: They balance professional aesthetics, quiet operation, and adequate security for employee access. The space-saving design maximizes lobby utility.
Primary Choice: Speed Gates
Why: Extreme throughput requirements make speed gates essential. Consider full-height variants for higher security areas.
Primary Choice: Sliding Turnstiles
Why: 24/7 operation demands quiet performance. The elegant design enhances property values without disturbing residents.
Primary Choice: Sliding Turnstiles
Why: Noise reduction is critical in medical environments. The smooth, gentle operation accommodates patients and medical equipment.
Primary Choice: Swing Gates
Why: Cost-effectiveness and durability in potentially harsh environments. The simpler mechanism handles industrial traffic well.
Mix Approach: Speed gates for high-traffic student areas, sliding turnstiles for faculty/administrative zones.
Choosing DOOR means more than selecting hardware—it's partnering with a complete solution provider:
Vertical integration: We control the manufacturing process from component production to final assembly
Quality assurance: Every turnstile undergoes 72-hour continuous operation testing before shipment
Customization capability: From color matching to specific dimension requirements
Pre-sale consultation: Free project analysis and recommendation
Integration expertise: Experience with 100+ access control and security systems
Global support network: 24/7 technical assistance with local language support
Modular architecture: Easily upgrade components as technology evolves
Software compatibility: Regular firmware updates for emerging protocols
Scalable solutions: Systems that grow with your facility needs
Prioritizing Price Over Total Cost: The cheapest option often costs more in maintenance and replacement
Ignoring Throughput Calculations: Underestimating peak traffic causes bottlenecks
Overlooking Integration Requirements: Ensure compatibility before purchase
Neglecting Maintenance Access: Consider service requirements in installation planning
Forgetting About Aesthetics: The turnstile becomes part of your building's identity
Request a Site Assessment: Contact DOOR for a free evaluation of your specific needs
Download Technical Specifications: Compare detailed specs of each turnstile type
Schedule a Demo: Experience the operation differences firsthand
Consult with Peers: Review case studies from similar facilities
Plan for Integration: Involve your IT/security team early in the process
The decision between sliding, swing, and speed gate turnstiles ultimately depends on your unique combination of space constraints, traffic patterns, security requirements, aesthetic preferences, and budget considerations.
For most modern commercial applications, sliding turnstiles represent the optimal balance—offering space efficiency, quiet operation, sophisticated security features, and architectural compatibility. Their slightly higher initial investment is typically offset by lower long-term maintenance costs and superior user experience.
As a manufacturer committed to innovation, Shenzhen DOOR continues to advance each technology. Our sliding turnstiles now incorporate AI-powered anti-tailgating algorithms, our swing gates feature enhanced durability for harsh environments, and our speed gates achieve industry-leading throughput without compromising security.
The right choice today will serve your facility for years to come. Make it with comprehensive information and expert guidance.
Headquarters Add.
Factory Add.
Come and Contact DOOR
Quick Links
17th Floor, Block C, Digital Innovation Center, Longhua District, Shenzhen, China
EN
